The severe consequences of an incorrectly executed deed

Businesses sign documents all the time. Some,

Businesses sign documents all the time. Some, however, must be executed as a "deed" and, for those, the law insists on particular formalities. If you make an error, the consequences can be considerable, as a document everyone intended to be binding, and which may have relied upon for years, can turn out to be legally worthless. A recent High Court decision shows exactly how this can happen and why the way in which a company signs really matters.

Deeds, and why the formalities matter

A deed is the most formal form of legal document. Indeed, some transactions can only be executed by deed, such as those transferring land, granting a power of attorney, or making a promise without anything being anticipated in return (e.g., a guarantee or gift). As deeds carry such weight, the law sets strict rules about how they must be signed.

The Companies Act 2006 offers two primary routes. A company can execute a deed with the signatures of two authorised signatories: two directors, or a director and the company secretary. Alternatively, a single director may sign, but only if that signature is “attested” by a witness. Attested, in this context, means that the witness is not merely present but actually signs the document to confirm that they actually saw the director sign. The document must also make it clear on its face that it is intended to be a deed and be delivered as such. These are not merely hollow technicalities; they exist so that deeds, which often carry serious legal consequences, are reliable and hard to dispute, and the price of that reliability is following them to the letter.

A power of attorney that never was

In the case in point, a private investment fund was structured as a limited partnership. The governing agreement contained a power of attorney which allowed the general partner to sign certain documents on behalf of every investor. Relying on that power, the general partner later signed a further agreement that purported to bind all the partners, including one investor who subsequently objected.

That investor argued that the power of attorney had never been validly created, because the original agreement had not been executed as a deed, and a power of attorney can only be granted by deed. The Court agreed with this contention. A single director had signed for the company, and while there was evidence that a witness was physically present, this did not materialise in the form of a signature. Under Section 44(2)(b) of the Companies Act 2006, physical presence itself is insufficient, and the witness must actively sign the deed to confirm the attestation. The agreement was therefore not a valid deed and so the power of attorney it contained was void, and the general partner could not bind the objecting investor to the latter agreement.

Just as importantly, this glaring oversight could not be retroactively patched over. The Court held that a document failing as a deed could not suddenly metamorphose into an ordinary contract granting the same authority, and the fact that the investor had already accrued benefits under the agreement did not stop the issue from challenging the point.

Implications:

The lessons are practical and apply to any company. The first is to treat execution as carefully as the process of drafting the document itself. When a document is to be a deed, confirm which signing route is being used and, if a single director signs, ensure that a witness, usually a public notary, is physically present and actually signs the attestation and is not just named in it.

The second is that these errors often surface at the worst possible moment, for instance during litigation, insolvency, or when someone wants to exit a deal – and by then such glaring oversights can be very difficult to fix. A party that previously relied on a defective power of attorney, guarantee, or transfer may find it has no enforceable right at all.

In summary:

  • Binding an investor to a change in corporate structure via a secondary agreement may require a witnessed Power of Attorney.
  • Partnership agreements may not be validly executed as deeds if a single director signs without a witness actively signing the attestation.
  • A Power of Attorney strictly requires a valid deed to exist, and a defective execution renders the power void and unenforceable.
  • A failed deed cannot retroactively transform into an ordinary contract to save the agreement, even if benefits were already accepted.
  • Formality is substance, and even minor signing errors under the Companies Act 2006 can completely invalidate high-value commercial agreements.

The wider message is that formality is substance when it comes to deeds. Powers of attorney, guarantees and property transfers are the very documents where signing incorrectly causes the most damage, so it is well worth checking the formalities of their execution and taking professional legal advice before signing, rather than after a dispute has begun.

Disclaimer:  This simplified summary of a UK legal case is for general information only. It is based on a claim issued in the High Court. It is not intended as legal advice, may omit important detail, and may not reflect any subsequent developments or appeals. Please read the full judgement and seek professional legal advice before acting.